Technically this is my 2nd P Class as I managed to get a Bluebell Pre-owned a few years ago for quite the markup (This was before Hattons announced the rerun). I was perfectly fine w/ the price for the performance and detail at $140, and I frequently called it "The Crown Jewel of my Collection".
Imagine my excitement when the reruns were announced and moved forward despite Hattons' closure. Now I have two brilliant little models, both with astounding detail and both are running smoother than butter. The detailing seems to have even been improved slightly, with writing on the ring of the crest being fairly legible (my Bluebell has a blemished crest on one side, though I'll chalk that up to the previous owner).
Minor Issues:
- Reports of cab steps being loose have been floating around. Mine had this issue (visible in 2 of the photos) and it sadly took a tiny bit of paint off with it. Re-Fitting the step is easy enough, but now I have to find some paint that will blend in with the back piece to at least mask the blemish.
- Whistle was mildly loose out of the box, decided to just pull the thing out n super glue it back into place. Easy fix.
- Tiiiiiny little scratch by all the pipework at the front of one of the tanks. Happened to catch this one basically by accident while examining the model fresh out of the box under a bright focused light. You will absolutely never notice something like this while it's on a layout, unlikely to notice while on display in a case. Personally, I don't really care about a scratch that tiny basically hiding behind all the brilliant detail right next to it, but I didn't want to leave it out of the review.
Suggestions for a buyer: Grab at least one. These things are beautifully decorated and are some of the best runners in my collection of around 40 different classes, all for an absolute bargain. First thing out of the box should be to check fitment around the steps and whistle.
Suggestions for Accurascale: Many of these issues (Especially the Barclay Industrials motor mounts) should've been caught during QC. Now that the Andrew Barclays and the P Classes both have had issues out of the box, the packaging needs to be revised (and you all acknowledge this because the Barclay fix mentions replacement packaging being shipped alongside the fix).
I think either the clamshell is too tight / rigid, or the foam is too rigid, so it doesn't provide enough shock absorption during transit. The almost comedically large box is nice, but if it doesn't actually protect the model from shocks then who cares.